By Monica Crowley
During the eight years of the George W. Bush presidency, the left constantly told us that "dissent is the highest form of patriotism." During the Obama presidency, dissent is routinely considered the lowest form of treachery.
Candidate Barack Obama promised to be a "new kind" of leader who would welcome vigorous debate and listen to all opinions. As president, however, he has shown a disturbing intolerance for any viewpoint other than his own. Rather than his promised post-partisan open-mindedness, his White House is using its power to try to smear and delegitimize those who oppose its agenda. With Orwellian coldness and efficiency, the administration has waged war on those who have had the gall to disagree with it:
The war on Fox News. White House Communications Director Anita Dunn projected big-time last week by calling Fox News "an arm of the Republican party." Yet Mr. Obama’s strategists have worked relentlessly to turn other networks into an arm of the Democratic Party. Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel is reported to hold weekly conference calls with CNN’s James Carville and Paul Begala and ABC News’ George Stephanopoulos. As Miss Dunn boasted early this year, Team Obama was able to "control" the media.
Last weekend, senior White House aides escalated the attack. Mr. Emanuel asserted that Fox wasn’t a "legitimate news organization," a point amplified by senior adviser David Axelrod: "They’re not really a news station. … It’s really not news. It’s pushing a point of view."
The White House’s complaint against Fox has nothing to do with news. It has everything to do with the fact that Fox is the only network to air consistently opposing points of view and treat them with respect. Fox ensures that its opinion shows, led by Bill O’Reilly, Glenn Beck and Sean Hannity, are separate and distinct from its news hours, which cannot be said of other networks. Witness the left-wing bias that permeates CNN’s "news" coverage during anchor Rick Sanchez’s daily broadcast. Last week, he repeated unsubstantiated lies about conservative radio talk-show host Rush Limbaugh and had to be browbeaten into issuing a half-hearted apology. Or witness any of MSNBC’s "news hours." Last week, anchor Dylan Ratigan accused opponents of Obamacare of "trying to derail health care … even if it means half the country dies."
Straight news reporting? Only in Obamaworld.
Fox News dares to report that there is another side to the debate. For that, it must be marginalized and attacked in order to delegitimize the opposition viewpoints it airs. Several weeks ago, Mr. Obama visited every Sunday morning talk show except for "Fox News Sunday," and the White House has said no administration officials will appear on Fox through the end of the year.
The White House has every other network in its pocket, so it freezes out the only one not prostrating itself. While Mr. Obama promised tolerance and magnanimity toward all viewpoints as a candidate, he has shown intolerance and vindictiveness as president.
The war on tea partiers and town-hall attendees. On April 15, hundreds of thousands of Americans gathered in more than 800 cities and towns to protest out-of-control government spending. The White House claimed the president was "unaware" of the tea parties. On Sept. 12, hundreds of thousands of protesters showed up in Washington, carrying the same anti-big-government, big- spending message. And again, the White House said it was "unaware" of the massive rally.
Throughout August, thousands of Americans confronted their legislators over the Democrats’ proposed radical overhaul of health care. Sincerely outraged, these citizens were ridiculed and dismissed by the administration and Democratic congressional leaders. Press Secretary Robert Gibbs mocked them as "the Brooks Brothers brigade in Florida in 2000" that displayed "manufactured anger." House Speaker Nancy Pelosi denigrated them as "AstroTurf."
Ignoring and then laughing at the concerns of average citizens is generally not the approach of mature leaders in a responsive democracy.